Skip to content
NOWCAST WLWT News 5 at 6:00
Watch on Demand
Advertisement

What could Issue 2 mean for you? A closer look at Ohio's drug pricing proposal

Opponents say Issue 2 would raise drug prices, while supporters say yes vote would be a body blow to Big Pharma

What could Issue 2 mean for you? A closer look at Ohio's drug pricing proposal

Opponents say Issue 2 would raise drug prices, while supporters say yes vote would be a body blow to Big Pharma

WEBVTT FUSIONAROUND A MEASURE THAT COULD HAVEA MAJOR IMPACT ON HOW OHIO PAYSFOR PRESCRIPTION DRUGS.IT'S NO SECRET THAT MEDICINE INAMERICA IS NOT CHEAP.WE ARE PAYING FOUR TO FIVETIMES MORE THAN ANY NATION INTHE WORLD.AND WE CONSUME MORE THAN ANYOTHER NATION IN THE WORLD.TODD: DAVID LITTLE HAS BEENCAMPAIGNING STATEWIDE IN SUPPORTOF OHIO ISSUE 2.I INVESTIGATED HIS CLAIM ONCOSTS AND COULDN'T FIND ANYTHINGTO REFUTE IT.BUT EVEN BASIC FACTS CAN TURNCONTROVERSIAL WHEN YOU STARTTALKING ABOUT THE PROPOSED LAWON PRESCRIPTION DRUG COSTS.>> THE PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRYIS TERRIFIED THAT THIS WILLPASS.TODD: BUT WHAT WOULD THEPROPOSED LAW DO AND WHY AREOPPONENTS RUNNING ADS LIKE THIS?>> IT SOUNDS TOO GOOD TO BE TRUEBECAUSE IT IS.TODD: ISSUE 2 WOULD REQUIREANYONE WHO GETS PRESCRIPTIONDRUGS PAID FOR BY THE STATE OFOHIO TO PAY NO MORE FORPRESCRIPTION DRUGS THAN THEPRICE PAID BY THE U.S.DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS.SUPPORTERS SAY ON AVERAGE, THATIS UP TO 24% LOWER THAN THEREGULAR PRICE DRUG COMPANIESCHARGE.IT WOULD ALSO REQUIRE THE STATEDEFEND ANY LAWSUITS AGAINST THEPROPOSAL.ISSUE 2 WOULD AFFECT DRUG PRICESFOR THE 4 MILLION OHIOANS WHOGET THEIR PRESCRIPTIONS THROUGHSTATE PROGRAMS, NOT THOSE WITHPRIVATE INSURANCE.BUT LITTLE SAYS EVERYONE WOULDBENEFIT IF OHIO SAVED HUNDREDSOF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS ON THEPRICE IT NOW PAYS FOR MEDICINE.>> THIS WOULD LOWER THE STATEPRICE THROUGH NEGOTIATION.AND NEGOTIATION IS AS AMERICANAS APPLE PIE.TODD: BUT CRITICS CONTEND ISSUE2 IS A BAD DEAL ALL THE WAYAROUND.>> IT WOULD MAKE THINGS MOREEXPENSIVE AS WELL AS JEOPARDIZETHE AVAILABILITY OF SOME OFTHESE MEDICINES.TODD: JASON KERSHNER IS WITHCINCINNATI'S CHAMBER OFCOMMERCE, ONE OF DOZENS OFORGANIZATIONS OPPOSED TO ISSUE2.HE ARGUES OHIO ALREADYNEGOTIATES WITH DRUG COMPANIESINCLUDING SECRETIVE DISCOUNTSFOR THE VA.KERSHNER SAYS IF ISSUE 2 PASSES,ANY NEGOTIATED DEALS BEYOND THEMINIMUM FEDERAL MANDATE WOULDVANISH.>> IF THIS ISSUE WERE TO PASSYOU WOULD ACTUALLY LOSE THOSEDISCOUNTS.AND SINCE WE DON'T KNOW WHATTHOSE PRICES ARE THAT THE VAPAYS, WE DON'T KNOW WHAT THEIMPACT WOULD BE, AND IT WOULDLIKELY INCREASE DRUG COSTS.TODD: WHILE KERSHNER SAYS ISSUE2 WOULD PUSH DRUG PRICES HIGHER,DAVID LITTLE CONTENDS A YES VOTEWILL DO JUST THE OPPOSITE BYMAKING BIG PHARMA FOCUS MORE ONPATIENTS THAN PROFITS.>> WE HAVE TO FORCE THEM TO DOIT, AND THAT'S WHY THEY'REKICKING AND SCREAMING TO MAKESURE IT DOESN'T HAPPEN IN OHIO.TODD: YOU CAN SEE HOWCOMPLICATED IT GETS.SINCE BOTH SIDES ARE MAKINGCOMPETING CLAIMS, THIS IS ABALLOT ISSUE THAT REQUIRES DOINGYOUR HOMEWORK.WE'VE PUT TOGETHER RESOURCES FORYOU TO GO MORE IN-DEPTH, BYGOING TO WLWT.COM.
Advertisement
What could Issue 2 mean for you? A closer look at Ohio's drug pricing proposal

Opponents say Issue 2 would raise drug prices, while supporters say yes vote would be a body blow to Big Pharma

It's no secret that medicine in America is not cheap."We're paying four to five times more than any nation in the world, and we consume more than any other nation in the world," said David Little, a communications consultant for Ohio Taxpayers for Lower Drug Prices.Little said Ohio voters can help reign in rising prescription drug costs by voting yes on Issue 2 during next month's election."The pharmaceutical industry is terrified that this will pass," he said.Little, a passionate supporter of Issue 2, has been touting the measure statewide.But what would the proposed law do, and why are opponents running ads saying if Issue 2 becomes law, drug prices could actually go up?Issue 2 would require the state of Ohio to pay no "more for prescription drugs than the price paid by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs." Supporters have said the VA pays, on average, 20 to 24 percent less for drugs than the regular price drug companies charge.Read ballot language hereIt would also make the state defend any future lawsuits against the proposal.Issue 2 would affect drug prices for approximately 4 million Ohioans who get their prescriptions through state programs. While not directly impacting people who have private insurance, Little said everyone in the state would benefit if Ohio were able to save hundreds of millions of dollars on the price the state pays for medicine."This would lower the state price through negotiation," Little said. "And negotiation is as American as apple pie."But critics contend Issue 2 is a bad deal all the way around."It would make things more expensive, as well as jeopardize the availability of some of these medicines," said Jason Kershner, vice president of government affairs for the Cincinnati USA Regional Chamber of Commerce, one of dozens of organizations opposed to Issue 2.Kershner argues Ohio already negotiates with drug companies. He also said the price the VA pays for drugs is secretive."If this issue were to pass, you would actually lose those discounts," Kershner said. "And since we don't know what those prices are that the VA pays, we don't know what the impact would be, and it would likely increase drug costs."While Kershner said Issue 2 would push drug prices higher, Little contends a yes vote will do just the opposite by making Big Pharma focus more on patients than profits."We have to force them to do it, and that's why they're kicking and screaming to make sure it doesn't happen in Ohio," Little said.Because there are so many competing claims, Issue 2 is a ballot issue that requires voters to carefully consider what both sides are saying.For example, the Ohio Pharmacists Association calls America's current drug pricing system "broken" and "anti-competitive," but the group opposes Issue 2, saying it could have "serious negative consequences" if it becomes law. Nearly 200,000 Ohioans signed petitions to get Issue 2 on the November ballot.A similar measure failed in California last year.

It's no secret that medicine in America is not cheap.

"We're paying four to five times more than any nation in the world, and we consume more than any other nation in the world," said David Little, a communications consultant for Ohio Taxpayers for Lower Drug Prices.

Advertisement

Little said Ohio voters can help reign in rising prescription drug costs by voting yes on Issue 2 during next month's election.

"The pharmaceutical industry is terrified that this will pass," he said.

Little, a passionate supporter of Issue 2, has been touting the measure statewide.

But what would the proposed law do, and why are opponents running ads saying if Issue 2 becomes law, drug prices could actually go up?

Issue 2 would require the state of Ohio to pay no "more for prescription drugs than the price paid by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs."

Supporters have said the VA pays, on average, 20 to 24 percent less for drugs than the regular price drug companies charge.

Read ballot language here

It would also make the state defend any future lawsuits against the proposal.

Issue 2 would affect drug prices for approximately 4 million Ohioans who get their prescriptions through state programs.

While not directly impacting people who have private insurance, Little said everyone in the state would benefit if Ohio were able to save hundreds of millions of dollars on the price the state pays for medicine.

"This would lower the state price through negotiation," Little said. "And negotiation is as American as apple pie."

But critics contend Issue 2 is a bad deal all the way around.

"It would make things more expensive, as well as jeopardize the availability of some of these medicines," said Jason Kershner, vice president of government affairs for the Cincinnati USA Regional Chamber of Commerce, one of dozens of organizations opposed to Issue 2.

Kershner argues Ohio already negotiates with drug companies. He also said the price the VA pays for drugs is secretive.

"If this issue were to pass, you would actually lose those discounts," Kershner said. "And since we don't know what those prices are that the VA pays, we don't know what the impact would be, and it would likely increase drug costs."

While Kershner said Issue 2 would push drug prices higher, Little contends a yes vote will do just the opposite by making Big Pharma focus more on patients than profits.

"We have to force them to do it, and that's why they're kicking and screaming to make sure it doesn't happen in Ohio," Little said.

Because there are so many competing claims, Issue 2 is a ballot issue that requires voters to carefully consider what both sides are saying.

For example, the Ohio Pharmacists Association calls America's current drug pricing system "broken" and "anti-competitive," but the group opposes Issue 2, saying it could have "serious negative consequences" if it becomes law.

Nearly 200,000 Ohioans signed petitions to get Issue 2 on the November ballot.

A similar measure failed in California last year.